Foreign Workers and Human Rights Violations: Malaysia's Response To COVID-19 and The Way Forward
Abstract
Foreign workforce has significantly contributed to Malaysia’s economy, and this country has been relying on them for decades. Unfortunately, Malaysia was already entangled with the country’s treatment of foreign workers even before the onset of COVID-19. As a government suppression attempt to flatten the COVID-19 pandemic curve, Malaysian efforts to deal with the situation seem to be at the lowest point. Despite the government’s commitment not to detain them throughout the screening process, foreign workers have been held in immigration depots regardless of their legal status. In addition, the overcrowded immigration depot makes it hard to exercise physical distance, hampers the quarantine process, and unequal health care facilities in detention centres. This situation captured worldwide attention since it violated human rights legislation. The protection of workers’ rights is also in tandem with the United Declaration of Human Rights and Sustainable Development Goals 2030 (SDG) 8.8, encouraging and ensuring everyone’s right to a safe and healthy workplace is protected. This paper employed thematic analysis using ATLAS.ti 9 software to evaluate the government’s suppression efforts and human rights violations during COVID-19. The findings propose numerous suggestions, including an emergency review of the admission process for foreign workers to Malaysia. The inconsistency in the government policy had hampered the country’s mission of becoming a developed nation. It thus hindered the advancement of innovation and technology, as in the Twelfth Malaysian Plan and Sustainable Development Goals 2030.
Keywords
Full Text:
PDFReferences
Abdul-Aziz, A. R. (2001). Bangladeshi Migrant Workers in Malaysia’s Construction Sector. Asia Pacific Population Journal, 16(1), 3-22.
Amnesty Organization. (2020). Crackdown on Migrants and Refugees an Appalling Violation of Human Rights, https://www.amnesty.my/2020/05/ 01/crackdown-on-migrants-and- refugees-an-appalling-violation-of- human-rights/ [3 August 2022].
Anon. (11 January 2017). Pekerja Asing: Antara Realiti Dan Persepsi. Berita Harian Online.
Anon. (18 February 2020). Now the World’s Hospitals Are Running out of Vital Rubber Gloves. The Time.
Anon. (20 March 2020). Human Resources Ministry Releases Faq During MCO Period. The Star.
Anon. (22 March 2020c). Don't Worry About Being Detained, Just Come Forward for Covid-19 Testing, Please. New Straits Times.
Anon. (1 April 2020f). NGOs Unhappy over New Rules for Food Aid Distribution. The Star.
Anon. (7 April 2020). MCO: Out-of- Work Foreigners Trying to Sneak out of Country. New Straits Times.
Anon. (8 April 2020). 6,000 near Masjid India Affected after 15 New Cases Found There. The Star.
Anon. (1 May 2020). Malaysia Detains Migrants, Refugees’ Amid Coronavirus Lockdown. Al Jazeera.
Anon. (2 May 2020). UN: Use alternatives to detention in fight against Covid-19. New Straits Times.
Anon. (3 May 2020d). New Cluster Detected at a Kl Construction Site. The Star.
Anon. (4 May 2020). Malaysian Bar Urges Putrajaya to Stop Rounding up Undocumented Migrants. Malay Mail.
Anon. (4 May 2020). Ismail Sabri: Compulsory Covid-19 Tests for All Foreign Workers (Updated). The Star.
Anon. (9 May 2020). Coronavirus: Some Laid Off Malaysians Competing with Migrant Workers over 3D Jobs - Dirty, Dangerous and Difficult’. The Straits Times.
Anon. (12 May 2020). Grant Testing Amnesty to Illegal Immigrants, Govt Urged. The Star.
Anon. (16 May 2020). Covid-19: 17 New Cases, 73 Recoveries, 1 Death. Malaysia Kini.
Anon. (25 May 2020). Kerajaan Berhak Ambil Tindakan Terhadap PATI. Berita Harian Online.
Anon. (25 May 2020c). New Covid-19 Cluster Detected at Kl Construction Site with 44 Cases. The Star.
Anon. (26 May 2020). Guna NGO, Pemimpin Warga Asing Pujuk Pati Bekerjasama’, Beriat Harian Online
Anon. (4 June 2020). COVID-19: Pendekatan Menyeluruh Tangani Jangkitan Kalangan Pekerja Asing. Berita Harian Online.
Anon. (13 June 2022). Malaysia Firms Turn Down Orders as Migrant Labour Shortage Hits. The Star.
Anon. (1 September 2020d). Long-Term Pass Holders from India, Indonesia and Philippines Barred Entry from Monday’. New Straits Times.
Anon. (9 November 2020). Kerajaan Beri Perhatian Peningkatan Covid-19 Di Kalangan Pekerja Asing. Sinar Harian.
Anon. (30 November 2020). 18 Points to Prevent Foreign Workers’ Virus Infection, New Straits Times.
Anon. (24 December 2020). Action against Employers Who Fail to Send Foreign Workers for Covid- 19 Screening. New Straits Times.
Anon. (5 January 2021). Pekerja Warga Asing Di Malaysia Positif Covid-19. Antara News.
Anon. (17 February 2021). Over 7k Foreign Workers Tested Positive for Covid-19, Says Ismail Sabri. The Star.
Anon (13 June 2022). Malaysia Firms Turn Down Orders as Migrant Labour Shortage Hits. The Star.
Anon. (1 July 2022). Indonesia to Phase out Domestic Helpers to Malaysia Eventually. The Star.
Anon. (13 July 2022). Hamzah: 712,435 Illegal Immigrants Registered under Recalibration Programmes. The Star.
Anon. (12 December 2021). Pengambilan Semula Pekerja Asing Bantu Pulih Perniagaan – FMM. Berita Harian Online.
Anon. (21 March 2024). Verification rate lags as RTK 2.0 deadline approaches. The Star.
Anon. (21 March 2024). Employers point out RTK 2.0 flaws. The Star.
Anon. (26 March 2024). Foreign workers not a long-term solution, says minister. New Straits Times.
Clarke, V., & Braun, V. (2013). Teaching Thematic Analysis: Overcoming Challenges and Developing Strategies for Effective Learning. The Psychologist, 26(2), 120-123.
Ganesan, P. (19 November 2020). Foreign Labour and Covid-19 Outbreaks. Malay Mail.
Hamid, A. R. A., Muhamad, N., Zakaria, R., Aminuddin, E., Alwee, A. A., & Tok, A. (2018). The Challenges of the Ageing Population on the Malaysian Construction Industry. Journal of Physics: Conference Series.
Human Rights Watch. (2020). Malaysia: End Abusive Immigration Detention Release Children; Allow Un Refugee Agency Access to Detained Migrants. Bangkok: https://www.hrw.org/news/2020/20 11/2020/malaysia-end-abusive-immigration-detention [20 August 2022].
International Labor Organization. (n.d). Covid-19: Impact on Migrant Workers and Country Response in Malaysia.
International Labor Organization. (2022). ‘Migration Overview’. Triangle in Asean Quarterly Briefing Note Malaysia ( January – June 2022 ).
Ismail, A. (2013). The Effect of Labour Shortage in the Supply and Demand of Palm Oil in Malaysia. Oil Palm Industry Economic Journal, 13(2), 15-26.
Kanapathy V. (n.d). Controlling Irregular Migration the Malaysian Experience, lLO Asian Regional Programme on Governance of Labour Migration Working Paper No.14 p 1-27.
Kassim, A. (2005). Cross-Border Movement of Foreign Workers in Malaysia: A Comparative Analysis. Master Builder, p 78-91.
Kassim, A. (2014). Recent Trends in Transnational Population Inflows into Malaysia: Policy, Issues and Challenges. Malaysian Journal of Economic Studies, 51(1), 9-28.
Kaur, A. (2010). Labour Migration Trends and Policy Challenges in Southeast Asia. Policy and Society, 29(4), 385-397.
Kumar K. (17 February 2016). Malaysians Shun ‘3D’ Jobs Because of Social Stigma, Not Low Wages, Employers Say, Malay Mail.
Lim, L. L. (1996). The Migration Transition in Malaysia. Asian and Pacific Migration Journal, 5(2-3), 319-337.
Loh, W. S., Simler, K., Tan Wei, K., & Yi, S. (2019). Malaysia-Estimating the Number of Foreign Workers: A Report from the Labor Market Data for Monetary Policy Task. The World Bank.
Low, C. C., & Mokhtar, K. S. (2017). Migration Control in Malaysia: Shifting toward Internal Enforcement. Asia-Pacific Social Science Review, 16(3), 46-64.
Lum. M. (2020). Covid-19 and Foreign Workers, Code Blue: Health is Human Right, Social Health Analytics Sdn Bhd. https://codeblue.galencentre.org/20 20/05/27/covid-19-and-foreign- workers/
Marhani, M. A., Adnan, H., Baharuddin, H. E., Esa, M. R., & Hassan, A. A. (2012). Dependency of Foreign Workers in Malaysian Construction Industry. Built Environment Journal, 9(1), 39-50.
Migration Data Portal. (2022). Migration Data Relevant for the Covid-19 Pandemic. https://www.migrationdataportal.or g/themes/migration-data-relevant- covid-19-pandemic.
Ministry of Health 2020. Daily Update on Covid-19, https://kpkesihatan.com. Ministry of Health. (2021). Situasi Semasa Pandemik Covid-19 Di Malaysia,
http://covid-19.moh.gov.my/ Ministry of Health Singapore 2020. Covid- 19 Situation Report, https://covidsitrep.moh.gov.sg/
Mustaffa, A., Noura, C., & Haque, M. M. (2021). Right of Migrant Workers to Occupational Health and Safety Under Malaysia Laws. International Journal of Law, Government, and Communication, 6(26), 48-60.
Noor, Z. M., Isa, N., Said, R., & Abd Jalil, S. (2011). The Impact of Foreign Workers on Labour Productivity in Malaysian Manufacturing Sector. Ministry of Higher Education, p 73-84.
Owen, N. G. (Ed.). (2006). The Emergence of Modern Southeast Asia: A New History. National University of Singapore (NUS) Press.
Richard H. A. & Ahmad A. (2014). Managing International Migration for Development in East Asia, World Bank Group.
Ritchie, Roser, Mispy and Ortiz-Ospina. (2018). Measuring Progress Towards The Sustainable Development Goals, Global Change Data Lab, https://sdg- tracker.org/
Robertson Jr, P. S., & Fair Labor Association. (2009). Migrant Workers in Malaysia-Issues, Concerns and Points for Action.
Rudnick, A. (1996). Foreign Labour in Malaysian Manufacturing: Bangladeshi Workers in the Textile Industry. Malaysia: INSAN Publisher.
Sandanasamy, F., Paavilainen, M., & Baruah, N. (2020). Covid-19: Impact on Migrant Workers and Country Response in Malaysia International Labour Organization. Regional Office for Asia and the Pacific.
SUHAKAM. (2020). SUHAKAM Urges Authorities to Cease Arrest of Undocumented Migrants During Covid-19 Crisis. Suhakam 2020. https://www.suhakam.org.my/press-statement-no-15-of-2020- suhakam-urges-authorities-to- cease-arrest-of-undocumented- migrants-during-covid-19-crisis//
Sukumaran, T. & Jaipragas, B., (2020). Coronavirus: Hundreds Arrested as Malaysia Cracks Down on Migrants in Covid-19 Red Zones. South China Morning Post.
The Economist. (2022). Covid in the Camps-Migrant Workers in Cramped Gulf Dorms Fear Infection, https://www.economist.com/middl e-east-and- africa/2020/04/23/migrant-workers-in-cramped-gulf-dorms- fear-infection
Twelfth Malaysia Plan 2021-2025. A Prosperous, Inclusive, Sustainable Malaysia, Economic Planning Unit.
United Nations, General Comment No 23, 2016.
Universal Declaration of Human Rights. 1948.
Wahab, A. (2020). The Outbreak of Covid- 19 in Malaysia: Pushing Migrant Workers at the Margin. Social Sciences & Humanities Open, 2(1), 1-9.
World Bank. (n.d). Potential Responses to the Covid-19 Outbreak in Support of Migrant Workers. “Living Paper” Version 8, p 1-41.
World Health Organization. (August 2020). Malaysia Strong Preparedness and Leadership for a Successful COVID-19 Response, COVID-19: Who’s Action in Countries.
Yee E. (29 April 2022). MEF: Special Approval for Refugees and Undocumented to Ease Labour Dearth. Business Today.
Zulkarnain I. & David N. (10 December 2021). Malaysia Bersetuju Buka Semula Pengambilan Pekerja Asing Untuk Semua Sektor. Benar News Malaysia.
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.