A Legal Scrutiny on the Auditors’ Role to Whistle-Blow

Loganathan Krishnan

Abstract


Auditors examine companies’ accounts and submit auditors’ reports. However, these duties augmented in recent years due to constant changes in the corporate atmosphere. Notably, many fraudulent activities and ventures were planned with the ingenious work and skill of auditors. Therefore, the guiding principles for auditors are responsibility and accountability so that auditors do not become part of the fraudulent activities. Thus, this study examines auditors’ role to whistle-blow any wrongful activities in a company. The study then examines the issues concerning auditors’ role to whistle-blow, to determine whether auditors are able to act as effective watchdogs. This is necessary due to the spate of financial scandals that occurred in Malaysia. Essentially, corporate law must ensure that the interests of shareholders and stakeholders are considered and hence the imposition of the duty on auditors to whistle-blow. Therefore, auditors must bear in mind the interests of the shareholders and stakeholders by countering the financial scandals through whistle-blowing. This can be achieved if auditors carry out their role to whistle-blow effectively. Additionally, the laws must be tightened to ensure that the duty to whistle-blow is legally realistic.

Keywords


auditors, whistle-blowing, corporate law

Full Text:

PDF

References


Aishah Bidin. 2001. Undang-Undang Syarikat Di

Malaysia. DBP. Kuala Lumpur.

Anon. 2001. Carolyn Hong, Fraud hits 62pc of listed

firms. New Straits Times, 8 June.

Anon. 2003. Ocean Capital Reclassified as PN4.

Business Times (Malaysia), 5 May.

Anon. 2007. BCHB Mulls Legal Action Over SBB

Audit. New Straits Times, 7 June: 39.

Anon. 2007. Audit on Southern Bank Properly

Conducted: Deloitte. New Straits Times, 8 June:

Anon. 2007. Transmile Audit Shows Losses in 2005,

New Straits Times, 19 June: 39.

Anon. 2007. Transmile Shares Extend Fall, SC Vows

Swift Action. New Straits Times, 21 June: 35.

Anon. 2007. Transmile: A Bumpy Ride. New Straits

Times, 25 June: 45.

Anon. 2007. Megan Media Posts RM1.27b Loss. New

Straits Times, 3 July: 36.

Anon. 2007. Megan Media in More Hot Water. New

Straits Times, 4 July: 39.

Anon. 2007. Transmile Rebounds Strongly. New Straits

Times, 4 July: 39.

Anon. 2007. Deloitte Defends Role in Transmile. New

Straits Times, 21 July: 27.

Anon. 2007. Steps to Improve Accounting Firms. New

Straits Times, 27 July: 43.

Anon. 2007. Transmile May Pick KPMG to be Auditor.

New Straits Times, 23 August: 39.

Anon. 2007. Local firms facing up to corporate crime:

PwC. New Straits Times, 25 October: 37.

Anon. 2009. Auditors raise ‘substantial doubts’ about

GM’s viability. New Straits Times, 6 March: B12.

Anon. 2009. Assessing integrity a tough task for audit

firms. New Straits Times, 10 March: B8.

Anon. 2009. Auditor charged with abetting firm in

submitting false info. New Straits Times, 29 April:

B2.

Anon. 2009. SSM believes in ‘balanced enforcement’.

New Straits Times, 3 December: B6.

Anon. 2010. SC: Step up vigilance on fraud. New Straits

Times, 12 January: B1.

Anon. 2010. External auditors raise red flags at 6

companies. New Straits Times, 1 May: B1.

Anon. 2010. SC probes Kenmark. New Straits Times, 2

June: B1.

Anon. 2010. Meeting with PwC to determine firm’s

actual debt. New Straits Times, 3 June: B2.

Anon. 2010. Ishak now a major investor in Kenmark.

New Straits Times, 4 June: B1.

Anon. 2010. SC: Yes Linear’s under our scrutiny. New

Straits Times, 18 June: B5.

Anon. 2010. No board nod for Linear fund transfer. New

Straits Times, 30 June: B1.

Anon. 2010. SC instructs BDO to further examine

SJAM’s books. New Straits Times, 30 June: B2.

Anon. 2010. SC starts probe into SJ Asset activities.New

Straits Times, 1 July: B1.

Anon. 2010. Auditor to complete Kenmark probe by

end-Aug. New Straits Times, 2 July: B2.

Anon. 2010. Bursa de-lists 95 firms for financial

problems. New Straits Times, 21 July: 13.

Baxt, R. 1970. The Modern Company Auditor: A

Nineteenth-Century Watchdog? MLR 33: 413.

Chambers, R.J. 1991. Accounting and Corporate

Morality: The Ethical Cringe. Australian Journal

of Corporate Law 1: 9.

David, R. 2006. Outside Audit: Backdating Woes Beg

the Question of Auditors’ Role. Wall Street Journal,

June: C1.

Easterby-Smith, M., Thorpe, R. & Lowe, A. 2002

Management Research: An Introduction. 2nd

Edition. London: Sage.

Geoffrey, R. M. 1989. Professional Negligence of

Lawyers, Accountants, Bankers and Brokers. 2nd

Edition. North Ryde N.S.W.: CCH Australia Ltd.

Greg, P. 1994. Auditors’ Obligations. Australian

Accountant 64(1): 50.

Jackson, R. M. & Powell, J.L. 1997. Professional

Negligence. 4th Edition. London: Sweet &

Maxwell.

Kahn, R. & Canneell, C. 1957. The Dynamics of

Interviewing. New York and Chichester: Wiley.

Krishnan, L. 2008. A Re-Assessment of Auditors’ Office

in Enhancing Accountability. IIUM Law Journal 16

(2): 263.

Krishnan, L. 2008. Corporate Responsibilities of Auditors

in Malaysia. Proceedings of 3rd International

Borneo Business Conference. Universiti Malaysia

Sabah, Kota Kinabalu, Sabah, Malaysia.

Krishnan, L. 2008. The Duties and Challenges Faced

by Auditors in Detecting Fraud. Proceedings of 3rd

International Conference on Law and Technology,

Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, Marriott Hotel,

Putrajaya, Federal Territory, Malaysia.

Krishnan, L. 2008. The Role of Auditors in the Banking

Sector. Proceedings of Applied International

Business Conference, Universiti Malaysia Sabah,

Labuan International Campus, Grand Dorsett,

Labuan, Federal Territory, Malaysia.

Krishnan, L. 2009. The Duties and Challenges Faced

by Auditors in Detecting Fraud. The Law Review

: 385.

Krishnan, L. 2009. Enhancing the Responsibilities of

Auditors in Malaysia. Current Law Journal Vol. 3:

i.

Krishnan, L. 2009. Ethical Duties of Auditors for

Effective Corporate Governance. Proceedings of the

th International Conference of the Asian Academy

of Applied Business: Managing Asian Business

Corporations in the 21st Century. Asian Institute

of Management, Conference Centre, Makati City,

Manila, Phillipines.

Krishnan, L. 2009. Accountability of Auditors Under

Criminal Law. Proceedings of International

Conference on Corporate Law, Universitas Air

Langga Surabaya. Indonesia.

Krishnan, L. 2010. Should Auditors Owe A Duty To

Stakeholders? The 2nd Management, Education and

Practice Conference Proceedings, Saint Mary’s

University, Garden Villa, Kaoshiung, Taiwan.

Krishnan, L. 2010. Examining the Effectiveness of

Regulators in Supervising the Conduct of Auditors

– 12th International Business Research Conference

Proceedings: Research for Rethinking. World

Business Institute, Australia, Crown Plaza Hotel,

Dubai, United Arab Emirates.

Lee, A.L. Economic Theory and Corporate Governance:

The Origins of Legislation on Company Directors’

Conflicts of Interest, 1862-1948, PhD Thesis,

University of Cambridge.

Nicholas, B. 1995. Company Law. 2nd Edition. London:

Cavendish.

Nicolas, D. 1988 Implications of Tort Rules of the

Accountant’s Liability for the Accounting Model.

Journal of Accounting, Auditing and Finance 3(3):

Normanton, E. L. 1996. The Accountability and Audit

of Governments. New York: Manchester University

Press.

Hanrahan, P., Ramsay, I., Stapledon, G., Aiman

Nariman Mohd Sulaiman & Aishah Bidin. 2002.

Commercial Applications of Company Law in

Malaysia. Singapore: CCH.

Peter, N. 2003. Audit Within the Framework of

Corporate Governance. In Klaus, J. H., Hamburg

& Eddy Wymeersch, Gent, (Eds.). Capital Markets

and Company Law. Oxford: Oxford University

Press.

Robson, C. 2002. Real World Research. 2nd Edition.

Oxford: Blackwell.

Roman, T. 1992. Auditors and the Reporting of Illegality

and Financial Fraud. ABLR 20: 198.

Saunders, M., Lewis, P. & Thornhill. 2007. Research

Methods for Business Students. Harlow: Prentice

Hall.

Simon, D. & Konzelmann, S.J. 2004. Learning From

Enron. Corporate Governance 1(12): 134.

Sin, Boon Ann.1990. The Duty of Care of Auditors: To

Whom Should the Duty be Owed. MLJ 3: iii.


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.