POTENTIAL USE OF FRESHWATER INSECT LARVAE IN RIVER BIOLOGICAL MONITORING: A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW

Ahmad Abas kutty, Suhaimi Hani Nazirah

Abstract


Freshwater insect larvae, also known as macroinvertebrates, are potential bio-indicators for water quality monitoring in Malaysia, as they were reported to have extensive density and distribution in Malaysian river ecosystems. The indices formed based on macroinvertebrate biogeographical data exhibited a good conjunction with the national water quality standard (NWQS) and water quality index (WQI) for monitoring the water quality in Malaysia. With a significant sensitivity, macroinvertebrates provide usable responses to environmental changes, which are highly similar to the water quality indices. Even these indices can provide an assessment of river quality faster and cheaper. This systematic study was conducted to demonstrate the potential use of macroinvertebrate-based available indices. Selected features evaluated are taxonomy level, type of indices, study area, and the similarity of the result with WQI. The survey was conducted using the Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) system consisting of eight stages of analysis. Manuscript searches have been conducted using Scopus and Web of Science search engines. Searched manuscripts were filtered according to the scope of the study and only manuscripts that meet the inclusion criteria were selected. A total of 184 manuscripts were found throughout the search and only 36 manuscripts were accepted for further analysis. Subsequently, the extraction of information from selected manuscripts was carried out, and each chosen issue's division was arranged in Microsoft excel. This study found that the most widely used biotic indices in Malaysia were Biological Monitoring Working Party (BMWP) followed by Average Score Per Taxon (ASPT), and the Family Biotic Index (FBI), while the most used diversity indices were the Shannon diversity index (H’) followed by the Margalef richness index (R’) and the Pielou evenness index (J). The family level was the most frequent for indices calculations compared to genus and species. Among all the indices used, BMWP was statistically proven to have the closest result to WQI, followed by the FBI, H’ and R’. The high similarity value with WQI proves that the macroinvertebrate's biotic and diversity indices are very significant in monitoring river ecosystem quality in Malaysia even if only at the family taxonomic level. These indices also showed small variations even in different rivers, demonstrates the suitability of many types of rivers in Malaysia.


Full Text:

PDF

References


Ab Hamid, S. & Rawi, C. 2017. Application of aquatic insects (Ephemeroptera, Plecoptera and Trichoptera) in water quality assessment of Malaysian headwater. Tropical Life Sciences Research 28(2): 143.

Ahmad, A.K., Abd Aziz, Z., Fun, H.Y., Ling, T.M. & Shuhaimi Othman, M. 2013. Makroinvertebrat Bentik sebagai Penunjuk Biologi di Sungai Kongkoi, Negeri Sembilan, Malaysia. Sains Malaysiana 42(5): 605-614.

Ahmad, A.K., Hafizah, A. & Aisyah, S.O.S. 2021. Chironomidae (Order: Diptera) diversity in relation to water quality of highland rivers at Cameron Highlands, Malaysia. Journal of Environmental Biology 42(3): 824 – 831.

Abas, A. 2021. A Systematic review on biomonitoring using lichen as the biological indicator: A decade of practices, progress and challenges. Ecological Indicators 121: 107197.

Al-Shami, S.A., Rawi, C.S.M., Ahmad, A.H., Hamid, S.A. & Nor, S. 2011. Influence of agricultural, industrial, and anthropogenic stresses on the distribution and diversity of macroinvertebrates in Juru River Basin, Penang, Malaysia. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety 74(5): 1195-1202.

Ammann, L.P., Waller, W.T., Kennedy, J.H., Dickson, K.L. & Mayer, F.L. 1997. Power, sample size and taxonomic sufficiency for measures of impact in aquatic systems. Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry 16(11): 2421-2431.

Armitage, P., Moss, D., Wright, J. & Furse, M.J. 1983. The performance of a new biological water quality score system based on macroinvertebrates over a wide range of unpolluted running-water sites. Water Research 17(3): 333-347.

Amila Faqhira, Z. & Suhaila, A.H. 2019. Drift pattern of tropical stream insect: Understanding the aquatic insects movement. Serangga 24(1): 1-10.

Bouchard Jr, R.W., Huggins, D. & Kriz, J. 2005. A Review Of The Issues Related To Taxonomic Resolution In Biological Monitoring Of Aquatic Ecosystems With An Emphasis On Macroinvertebrates. The University of Kansas: Central Plains Center for BioAssessment Kansas Biological Survey Lawrence.

Castillo-Figueroa, D., Garzón-Salamanca, L.L. & Albarracín-Caro, J.F. 2018. Aquatic macroinvertebrates as water quality bioindicators in Colombia: A systematic review. Neotropical Biology and Conservation 13(3): 235-248.

Chessman, B.C. & Royal, M.J. 2004. Bioassessment without reference sites: Use of environmental filters to predict natural assemblages of river macroinvertebrates. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 23(3): 599-615.

Dhiya Shafiqah, R., Che Salmah, M.R. & Suhaila, A.H. 2020. Seasonal influence on stricturing aquatic insects communitoes in upstream rivers Belum-Temenggor Forest Complex. Serangga 25(3): 101-115.

Feminella, J.W. 2000. Correspondence between stream macroinvertebrate assemblages and 4 ecoregions of the southeastern USA. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 19(3): 442-461.

Friberg, N., Sandin, L., Furse, M.T., Larsen, S.E., Clarke, R.T. & Haase, P. 2006. Comparison of macroinvertebrate sampling methods in Europe. In. Furse, M.T. et al. (eds.). The Ecological Status of European Rivers: Evaluation and Intercalibration of Assessment Methods, pp. 365-378. Springer Science & Business Media: Springer Dordrecht.

Ghani, W.M.H.W.A. 2016. Development of malaysian water quality indices using aquatic macroinvertebrates population of Pahang River Basin, Pahang, Malaysia. Doctoral Dissertation. Universiti Sains Malaysia.

Hellawell, J.M. 2012. Biological Indicators of Freshwater Pollution and Environmental Management. Springer Science & Business Media: Springer Dordrecht.

Hettige, N.D., Hashim, R.B., Kutty, A.B.A., Jamil, N.R.B. & Ash’aari, Z.H.B. 2020. Application of ecological indices using macroinvertebrate assemblages in relation to aquaculture activities in Rawang Sub-Basin, Selangor River, Malaysia. Pertanika Journal of Science & Technology 28(S2): 25-45.

Jones, F.C. 2008. Taxonomic sufficiency: The influence of taxonomic resolution on freshwater bioassessments using benthic macroinvertebrates. Environmental Reviews 16: 45-69.

Kalyoncu, H. & Zeybek, M. 2011. An application of different biotic and diversity indices for assessing water quality: A case study in the Rivers Cukurca and Isparta (Turkey). International Journal of Agricultural Sciences 9(5): 1-9.

Kutty, A.A., Fauzi, N.M., Satar, N.-A., Rak, A.E. & Omar, S.A.S. 2019. Potensi makroinvertebrat bentik sebagai penunjuk biologi di ekosistem sungai rekreasi. Serangga 24(1): 42-57.

Kutty, A.A., Mahali, M. & Mohamed, Z. 1999. Kajian pemonitoran biologi menggunakan makroinvertebrat di Hulu Sungai Langat, Selangor. Borneo Science 6: 45-46.

Moher, D., Liberati, A., Tetzlaff, J. & Altman, D.G. 2009. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. BMJ 2009; 339: b2535.

Muhammad Adam, I. & Amirrudin, B.A. 2024. Species richness and composition of odonata in four swamp forests of Terengganu, Peninsular Malaysia. Serangga 29(2): 128-149.

Ng, Y.F. & Nurul Afiqah, M. 2023. Inventori kekayaan spesies pepatung (odonata) pemangsa di sekitar habitat sawah di Sungai Panjang, Hulu Selangor, Malaysia. Serangga 28(3): 240-249.

Nurhafizah-Azwa, S. & Ahmad, A.K. 2018. Biodiversity of benthic macroinvertebrates in Sungai Kisap, Langkawi, Kedah, Malaysia. Journal of Tropical Resources and Sustainable Science 6(1): 36-40.

Ortiz, J. & Puig, M. 2007. Point source effects on density, biomass and diversity of benthic macroinvertebrates in a Mediterranean Stream. River Research and Applications 23(2): 155-170.

Paisley, M., Trigg, D. & Walley, W. 2014. Revision of the biological monitoring working party (Bmwp) score system: Derivation of present‐only and abundance‐related scores from field data. River Research and Applications 30(7): 887-904.

Salmiati, N.Z.A. & Salim, M.R. 2017. Integrated approaches in water quality monitoring for river health assessment: Scenario of Malaysian river. In. Tutu, H. (ed.). Water Quality, pp. 315-335. London: IntechOpen Limited.

Sabina Noor, R., Nosheen, A., Palwasha, Z., Saima, W., Sana, S. & Farzana. 2021. A preliminary study on aquatic insect diversity and abundance in relation to fluctuating physiochemical parameters of an artificial pond. Serangga 26 (4): 175-188.

Suhaila, A.H., Siti Hamidah, I., Norshamiera, N., Amila Faqhira, Z. & Mohd Hafizul Hasmadi, M.N. 2018. Aquatic insects assemblage in Penang Botanic Garden. Serangga 23(1): 46-57.

Stribling, J.B., Pavlik, K.L., Holdsworth, S.M. & Leppo, E.W. 2008. Data quality, performance, and uncertainty in taxonomic identification for biological assessments. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 27(4): 906-919.

Walley, W.J. & Fontama, V.N. 1998. Neural network predictors of average score per taxon and number of families at unpolluted river sites in Great Britain. Water Research 32(3): 613-622.

Walley, W. & Hawkes, H.J. 1997. A computer-based development of the biological monitoring working party score system incorporating abundance rating, site type and indicator value. Water Research 31(2): 201-210.

Yap, S.Y. 1997. Classification of a Malaysian river using biological indices: A preliminary attempt. The Environmentalist 17: 79–86.

Zakaria, M.Z. & Mohamed, M. 2019. Comparative analysis of biotic indices in water quality assessment: Case study at Sg. Bantang, Johor. IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science 269(1): 012047.


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.