Differential Ethnic Involvement in the Penang Tourist Industry: Some Policy Implications*

ABDUL KADIR HJ. DIN (kadir@uum.edu.my)

Abstract


This paper draws attention to the ethnic impact of tourism on the plural society of Penang. It suggests that extant models on tourism development pay inadequate attention to the multiethnic character of the host community which may serve to determine the manner in which benefits from tourism are distributed. Using Penang as an example, it attempts to describe the process which gives rise to ethnic dominance in the industry, and suggests some measures which can be taken to sustain the attractive plural outlook of the island as a tourist destination.

ABSTRAK

Kertas ini memberi perhatian kepada kesan pelancongan terhadap kedudukan masyarakat majmuk di Pulau Pinang. Penulisan yang ada tentang kesan pelancongan tidak menonjolkan perkara ini walaupun ciri majmuk ini sendiri adakalanya boleh menentukan pola agihan faedah dari pelancongan. Dengan merujuk kepada kedudukan di Pulau Pinang, kertas ini cuba menghuraikan proses dominasi etnik dalam industri pelancongan, dan mencadangkan beberapa langkah yang boleh diambil bagi mengekalkan wajah masyarakat majmuk yang merupakan satu daya tarikan penting bagi destinasi pelancongan tersebut.


Full Text:

PDF

References


Aldrich, H., T.P. Jones, and D. McEvoy. 1984. Ethnic advantage and minority business development. In Ethnic Communities in Business: Strategies for Economic Survival Eds. by Ward, R. and jenkins R., Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 189-211.

Begbie, P.J. 1967. The Malayan peninsula. Kuala Lumpur: OUP.

Britton, S. 1981. Tourism, dependency and development: A mode of analysis. Occasional Paper No.23 Development Studies Centre ANU.

Butler, R.W.1980. The concept of a tourist area cycle of evolution: Implications for management of resource. Canadian Geographer 24 (1): 914.

Chow, W.T. 1977. Tourism policy and regional development in Hawaii. Paper printed at the 40th Annual Meeting. Assn. of Pacifc Coast Geographers. ILO. June. 20-24.

Cohen, E. 1983. Insiders and Outsiders. The dynamics of development of bungalow tourism on the islands of Southern Thailand. Human Organization 42 (2) 158-162.

Davis, D. 1956. Old Penang. Singapore: Donald Moore.

Drake, P.J. 1978. The economic development of British Malaya to 1914: An essay in historiography with some questions for historians. (xerox): 262-290.

Furnivall, J.S. 1956. Colonial Policy and Practice. NY Univ. Press .

Gamier, K. 1923. The Early Days in Penang. JMBRAS 1: 5-12.

Goh, J.H. 1962. Some aspects of the Chinese business world in Malaya. Ekonomi 3: 84-95.

Heussler, R. 1981. British Rule in Malaya: The Malayan Civil Service and its Predecessors 1867-1942. Conn: Greenwood Press.

Higgins, B. 1983. From growth poles to system interactions in space. Growth and Change 14 (4): 3-13.

Hang, E. 1985. See the Third World While it lasts: The social and environmental impact of tourism with special reference to Malaysia. Penang: CAP.

Howard, H. 1971. The problem of tourism Financial Times, July 1, : 5.

Jackson, P. and S. Smith: 1984. Exploring Social Geography. London: George Allen and Unwin.

Johnson, J. 1807. The Oriental Voyager or Description. Sketches and Cursory Remarks on Voyage to India and China in His Majesty’s ship London.

Jones G.W. 1965. The employment characteristics of small downs in Malaya. Malayan Econ. Review 10 (1): 44-1.

Kratz E.U. 1981. The journey to the Fat, 17th century German Travel Books as sources of study. JAMBRAS 54 (1) 65-81.

Light, I. 1972. Ethnic Enterprise in America: Business and welfare Among Chinese. Japanese and Black. Univ. of Calif. Press.

Lim, B.B. 1979. A Socioeconomic study of Chinese Family Business with Particular Reference to the Coffeeshop Trade. MA Thesis University of Malaya.

Low, J. 1972. The British Settlement of Penang. London: OUP. (reprinted).

Mokhtar Halim. 1982. Malaysia. In Social and Economic Impact of Tourism on Asian Pacific Region, by D.E. Hawkins, Tokyo: Asian Productivity Organization.

Rajotte F. 1981. A Comparison of the Impact of Tourism between the Traditional Safari Regions and the Newer Coastal Resorts in Kenya. Mimeo.

Samy, J. 1974. Crumbs from the tables. In B. Finney &K. Watson (eds.) A new kind of Sugar. Honolulu: East-West Center.

Sandhu, K.S. 1973. Ancient Malaysia. Singapore: University Edition Press.

Singh, Chet. 1975. Regional economic development: The Role of Penang in northern Malaysian development. In Malaysian Economic Development and Policies, Stephen Chee and Siew Mun, MEA, Kuala Lumpur 1980: 269-278.

Snodgrass. D.R. 1980. Inequality and Income Distribution in Malaysia. Kuala Lumpur: OUP.

Sobhan. R. 1983. Regional Disparities sod the National Question: An Asian Perspective. Journal of Contemporary Asia. 13 (I): 91-108.

Tengku Idaura Iskandar. 1985. Towards a state tourism policy. Paper presented at the Convention on the Future of Penang, Penang, 6th May.

Tham, S.C. 1977. Malays and Modernization. Singapore.

Tourist Development Corporation Malaysia, 1975. Malaysia Tourism Development Plan. Kuala Lumpur: TDC.

Wilkinson H. 1983. Sunny Lands and Seas. London.

Wu, C.T. 1982. Issues of tourism and socioeconomic development. Annals of Tourism Research 9 (3): 317-330.

Yahya Ismail. 1978. Masalah Melayu Pulau Pinang. Kuala Lumpur: Dinamika Kreatif.

Yong, M.L. 1981. Migrants and niches: Economic structure of migration streams in peninsular Malaysia, 1965-70, USM Mimeo.


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


ISSN: 0126-5008

eISSN: 0126-8694