COMPARATIVE ANALYSES OF BIOTIC INDICES BASED ON BENTHIC MACROINVERTEBRATES FOR STREAM WATER QUALITY ASSESSMENT AT TROPICAL STREAMS

Wong Andrew Bak Hui, Arman Hadi Fikri

Abstract


Biotic indices application to other countries required testing and adaptations to local environments. However, their testing remains lacking in Malaysia. Therefore, this study analysed the performance of various biotic indices, in their sensitivity, responses, and seasonal stability. Fifteen sampling sites composed of reference and disturbed sites were selected and 14 indices were analysed for their performance. These indices include the Ephemeroptera, Plecoptera, and Trichoptera (EPT), Hilsenholf’s Family Biotic Index (FBI), Original Biological Monitoring Work Party (BMWP), Original Average Score Per Taxa (ASPT), Thailand’s Biological Monitoring Work Party (BMWP-Thai), Thailand’s Average Score Per Taxa (ASPT-Thai), Vietnam’s Biological Monitoring Work Party (BMWP-Thai), Vietnam’s Average Score Per Taxa (ASPT-Viet), South Africa Score System Version 5 (SASS5), ASPT of South Africa Score System Version 5 (ASPT-SASS5), Stream Invertebrate Grade Number Average Level Version 2 (SIGNAL2), and Singapore’s Biotic Index (SingScore), Malaysian Biological Monitoring Work Party (BMWP-My), and Malaysian Family Biotic Index (MFBI). Among the tested biotic indices, the EPT, BMWP-Thai, BMWP-Viet, SASS5, and BMWP-My were sensitive in discriminating the reference from disturbed sites. Most indices had significant linear relationships with phosphates, except the ASPT and ASPT-Thai. Meanwhile, EPT, BMWP-Viet, and BMWP-My were also associated with the habitat scores significantly. While only four biotic indices showed significant differences seasonally, the water quality classification between seasons was highly varied. In conclusion, EPT, BMWP-Viet, and BMWP-My showed better performances in discriminating the reference sites from disturbed sites, while associated with both phosphate and habitat score. As the water quality classification was highly varied seasonally, it is recommended to calculate the biotic indices during the dry season.


Full Text:

PDF

References


Abdullah, M.H. 2012. Principles in water quality analysis. Penerbit Universiti Malaysia Sabah.

Arman, N.Z., Salmiati, S., Mohd Said, M.I. & Aris, A. 2019. Development of macroinvertebrate-based multimetric index and establishment of biocriteria for river health assessment in Malaysia. Ecological Indicators 104: 449–458.

Armitage, P.D., Moss, D., Wright, J.F. & Furse, M.T. 1983. The performance of a new biological water quality score system based on macroinvertebrates over a wide range of unpolluted running-water sites. Water Research 17(3): 333-347.

Arsad, A., Abustan, I., Rawi, C.S.M. & Syafalni, S. 2012. Integrating biological aspects into river water quality research in Malaysia: an opinion. OIDA International Journal of Sustainable Development 4(2): 107-122.

Azmi, W.A. & Geok, H.A. 2016. aquatic insect communities in relation with water quality of selected tributaries of Tasik Tenyir Terengganu. Journal of Sustainability Science and Management 11(2): 11-20.

Bae, M.J., Kwon, Y.S., Hwang, S.J., Chon, T.S., Yang, H.J., Kwak, I.S., Park H.H., Ham, S.A. & Park Y.S. 2011. Relationships between three major stream assemblages and their environmental factors in multiple spatial scales. Annales de Limnologie 47: S91–S105.

Baker, K., Chadwick, M.A. & Sulaiman, Z.H. 2016. Eco-hydromorphic classification for understanding stream macroinvertebrate biodiversity in Brunei Darussalam, Northern Borneo. Zoological Studies 55: 37.

Barbour, M.T., Gerritsen, J., Griffith, G.E., Frydenborg, R., Mccarron, E. & Bastian, M.L. 1996. A framework for biological criteria for Florida streams using benthic macroinvertebrates. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 15(2): 185-211.

Barbour, M.T., Gerritsen, J., Snyder, B.D. & Stribling, J.B., 1999. Rapid bioassessment protocols for use in streams and wadeable rivers: periphyton, benthic macroinvertebrates, and fish. Washington: US Environmental Protection Agency.

Blakely, T.J., Eikaas, E.S. & Harding, J.S. 2014. The SingScore: A macroinvertebrate biotic index for assessing the health of streams and canals. Raffles Bulletin of Zoology 62: 540–548.

Buss, D.F., Carlisle, D.M., Chon, T.S., Culp, J., Harding, J.S., Keizer-Vlek, H.E., Robinson, W.A., Strachan, S., Thirion, C. & Hughes, R.M. 2015. Stream biomonitoring using macroinvertebrates around the globe: a comparison of large-scale programs. Environmental monitoring and assessment 187(1): 4132.

Carlson, P.E., Donadi, S. & Sandin, L. 2018. Responses of macroinvertebrates to small dam removals: implications for bioassessment and restoration. Journal of Applied Ecology 55(4): 1896-1907.

Chang, F.H., Lawrence, J.E., Rios-Touma, B. & Rehs, V.H. 2014. Tolerance values of benthic macroinvertebrates for stream biomonitoring: assessment of assumptions underlying scoring systems worldwide. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment 186: 2135–2149.

Chessman, B.C. 2003. New sensitivity grades for Australian river macroinvertebrates. Marine and Freshwater Research 54(2): 95-103.

Chessman, B.C. & McEvoy, P.K. 1998. Towards diagnostic biotic indices for river macroinvertebrates. Hydrobiologia 364: 169–182.

Choo, A. M. S. 2003. The impact of land use changes on the riverine environment of Liwagu-Labuk River Basin in Sabah. M.Sc Thesis, Universiti Malaysia Sarawak.

Davis, S.J., Ó hUallacháin, D., Mellander, P.E., Kelly, A.M., Matthaei, C.D., Piggott, J.J. & Kelly-Quinn, M. 2018. Multiple-stressor effects of sediment, phosphorus and nitrogen on stream macroinvertebrate communities. Science of the Total Environment 637–638: 577–587.

Dickens, C.W.S. & Graham, P.M. 2002. The South African Scoring System (SASS) version 5 rapid bioassessment method for rivers. African Journal of Aquatic Science 27: 1-10.

Elias, J.D., Ijumba, J.N. & Momboya, F.A. 2014. Effectiveness and compatibility of non-tropical bio-monitoring indices for assessing pollution in tropical rivers-a review. International Journal of Ecosystem 4(3): 128-134.

Etemi, F.Z., Bytyçi, P., Ismaili, M., Fetoshi, O., Ymeri, P., Shala-Abazi, A., Muja-Bajraktari, N. & Czikkely, M. 2020. The use of macroinvertebrate based biotic indices and diversity indices to evaluate the water quality of Lepenci river basin in Kosovo. Journal of Environmental Science and Health Part A 55(6): 748-758.

Ferreira, W.R., Ligeiro, R., Macedo, D.R., Hughes, R.M., Kaufmann, P.R., Oliveira, L.G. & Callisto, M. 2014. Importance of environmental factors for the richness and distribution of benthic macroinvertebrates in tropical headwater streams. Freshwater Science 33(3): 860-871.

Fitzpatrick, F.A., Scudder. B.C., Lenz, B.N. & Sullivan, D.J. 2001. Effects of multi-scale environmental characteristics on agricultural stream biota in eastern Wisconsin. Journal of American Water Resource Association 37:1489–1507.

Friberg, N., Sandin, L. & Pedersen, M.T. 2009. Assessing the effects of hydromorphological degradation on macroinvertebrate indicators in rivers: Examples, constraints, and outlook. Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management 5(1): 86–96.

Gazendam, E., Gharabaghi, B., Jones, F.C. & Whiteley, H. 2011. Evaluation of the qualitative habitat evaluation index as a planning and design tool for restoration of rural Ontario waterways. Canadian Water Resources Journal 36(2): 149-158.

Ghani, W.M.H.W.A. 2016 Development Of Malaysian Water Quality Indices Using Aquatic Macroinvertebrates Population Of Pahang River Basin, Pahang, Malaysia. PhD Thesis, Universiti Sains Malaysia.

Ghani, W.M.H.W.A., Kutty, A.A., Mahazar, M.A., Al-Shami, S.A. & Hamid, S.A. 2018. Performance of biotic indices in comparison to chemical-based Water Quality Index (WQI) in evaluating the water quality of urban river. Environmental Monitoring Assessment 190: 297.

Gillies, C.L., Hose, G.C. & Turak, E. 2009. What do qualitative rapid assessment collections of macroinvertebrates represent? A comparison with extensive quantitative sampling. Environmental Monitoring Assessment 149: 99-112.

Harun, S. & Fikri, A.H. 2016. Water quality monitoring in Sugut River and its tributaries. WWF-Malaysia Project Report, February.

Harun, S., Al-Shami, S.A., Dambul, R., Mohamed, M. & Abdullah, M.H. 2015. Water quality and aquatic insects study at the Lower Kinabatangan River Catchment, Sabah: In response to Weak la niña event. Sains Malaysiana 44(4): 545-558.

Hauer, F.R. & Resh, V.H. 2007. Benthic macroinvertebrates. In. Hauer, F.R. & Lamberti, G. A. (ed.). Methods in Stream Ecology, pp. 339-370. California: Academic Press.

Hazelton, P. 2003. Analysis of Ephemeroptera, Plecoptera and Trichoptera (EPT) richness and diversity of Guilford Creek, Guilford, NY. Oneonta: State University of New York.

Heatherly II,T. & Whiles, M.R. 2007. Relationships between water quality, habitat quality, and macroinvertebrate assemblages in Illinois Streams. Journal of Environmental Quality 36(6):1653-166.

Heino, J., Muotka, T., Mykrä, H., Paavola, R., Hämäläinen, H. & Koskenniemi, E. 2003. Defining macroinvertebrate assemblage types of headwater streams: implications for bioassessment and conservation. Ecological Applications 12(3): 842-852.

Helson, J.E. & Williams, D.D. 2013. Development of a macroinvertebrate multimetric index for the assessment of low-land streams in the neotropics. Ecological Indicators 29: 167-178.

Hilsenhoff, W.L. 1988. Rapid field assessment of organic pollution with a family-level biotic index. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 7(1): 65-68.

Huong, H.T.T. 2009. Monitoring and assessment of macroinvertebrate communities in support of river management in northern Vietnam. PhD Thesis, Ghent University, Belgium.

Kilonzo, F., Masese, F.O.,Van Griensven, A., Bauwens, W., Obando, J. & Lens, P.N.L. 2014. Spatial–temporal variability in water quality and macro-invertebrate assemblages in the Upper Mara River basin, Kenya. Physics and Chemistry of the Earth 67–69: 93–104.

Larsen, D.P. 1997. Sample survey design issues for bioassessment of inland aquatic ecosystems. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment: An International Journal 3(6): 979-991.

Lenat, D.R. 1993. A biotic index for the Southeastern United States: derivation and list of tolerance values, with criteria for assigning water-quality ratings. Journal of North American Benthological Society 12(3): 279-290.

Lenat, D.R. 1996. History of the EPT taxa richness metric. Bulletin of the North American Benthological Society 13: 305-307.

Li, L., Zheng, B.H. & Liu, L.S. 2010. Biomonitoring and bioindicators used for river ecosystems: definitions, approaches and trends. Procedia Environmental Sciences 2: 1510–1524.

Lorenz, A., Hering, D., Feld, C.K. & Rolauffs, P. 2004. A new method for assessing the impact of hydromorphological degradation on the macroinvertebrate fauna of five German stream types. Hydrobiologia 516: 107–127.

Mahazar, A., Shuhaimi-Othman, M. & Kutty, A.A. 2013. Benthic macroinvertebrate as biological indicator for water quality in Sungai Penchala. AIP Conference Proceedings 1571: 602.

Maul, J.D., Farris, J.L., Milam, C.D., Cooper, C.M., Testa III, S. & Feldman, D.L. 2004. The influence of stream habitat and water quality on macroinvertebrate communities in degraded streams of northwest Mississippi. Hydrobiologia 518: 79-94.

Mazzoni, A.C., Lanzer, R. & Schafer, A. 2014. Tolerance of benthic macroinvertebrates to organic enrichment in highland. Acta Limnologica Brasiliensia 26(2): 119-128.

Moraes, A.B., Wilhelm, A.E., Boelter, T., Stenert, C., Schulz, U.H. & Maltchik, L. 2014. Reduced riparian zone width compromises aquatic macroinvertebrate communities in streams of southern Brazil. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment 186(11): 7063–7074.

Morse, J.C., Yang, L.F. & Tian, L.X. 1994. Aquatic Insects of China Useful for Monitoring Water Quality. Nanjing: Hohai University.

Mukaka, M.M. 2012. Statistics Corner: A guide to appropriate use of correlation coefficient in medical research. Malawi Medical Journal 24(3): 69-71.

Murtedza, M., Oksen, P. & Müller, T. 2002. Land use zones and land use conflicts in the Liwagu-Labuk River Basin, Sabah, East-Malaysia. Conference on International Agricultural Research for Development, Witzenhausen. 9-11 October.

Mustow, S.E. 2002. Biological monitoring of rivers in Thailand: use and adaptation of the BMWP score. Hydrobiologia 479: 191–229.

Naubi, I., Zardari, N.H., Shirazi, S.M., Ibrahim, N.F.B. & Baloo, L. 2016. Effectiveness of water quality index for monitoring Malaysian river water quality. Polish Journal of Environmental Studies 25(1): 231-239.

Ng, T.H., Dulipat, J., Foon, J.K., Lopes-Lima, M., Zieritz, A. & Liew, T.S. 2017. A Preliminary checklist of the freshwater snails of Sabah (Malaysian Borneo) deposited in the BORNEENSIS collection, Universiti Malaysia Sabah. ZooKeys 673: 105-123.

Ochieng, H., Odong, R. & Okot-Okumu, J. 2020. Comparison of temperate and tropical versions of Biological Monitoring Working Party (BMWP) index for assessing water quality of River Aturukuku in Eastern Uganda. Global Ecology and Conservation 23: e01183.

Ochieng, H., Okot-Okumu, J. & Odong, R. 2019. Taxonomic challenges associated with identification guides of benthic macroinvertebrates for biomonitoring freshwater bodies in East Africa: A review. African Journal of Aquatic Science 44(2): 113-126.

Ridzuan, D.S., Rawi, C.S.M. & Hamid, S.A. 2020. Seasonal influence on structuring aquatic insects communities in upstream rivers Belum-Temengor forest complex. Serangga 25(3): 101-115.

Sandin, L. & Johnson, R.K. 2000. The statistical power of selected indicator metrics using macroinvertebrates for assessing acidification and eutrophication of running waters. Hydrobiologia 422-423: 233-243.

Schober, P., Boer, C. & Schwarte, L.A. 2018. Correlation coefficients: Appropriate use and interpretation. Anesthesia & Analgesia 126(5): 1763-1768.

Semenchenko, V.P. & Moroz, M.D. 2005. Comparative analysis of biotic indices in the monitoring system of running water in a biospheric reserve. Water Resources 32(2): 200-203.

Serrano Balderas, E.C., Grac, C., Berti-Equille, L. & Armienta Hernandez, M.A. 2016. Potential application of macroinvertebrates indices in bioassessment of Mexican streams. Ecological Indicators 61: 558–567.

Shi, X., Liu, J.L., You, X.G., Bao, K. & Meng, B. 2019. Shared effects of hydromorphological and physico-chemical factors on benthic macroinvertebrate integrity for substrate types. Ecological Indicators 105: 406-414.

Smith, A.J., Rickard, S., Mosher, E.A., Lojpersberger, J.L., Heitzman, D.L., Duffy, B.T. & Novak, M.A. 2015. Bronx river-biological stream assessment. 1 May. NYS Department of Environmental Conservation Report.

Stark, J.D. & Phillips, N. 2009. Seasonal variability in the macroinvertebrate community index: Are seasonal correction factors required? New Zealand Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research 43(4): 867-882.

Tan, K.W. & Beh, W.C. 2015. Water quality monitoring using biological indicators in Cameron Highlands Malaysia. Journal of Sustainable Development 8(3): 28-42.

Visinskiene, G. & Bernotiene, R. 2012. The use of benthic macroinvertebrate families for river quality assessment in Lithuania. Central European Journal of Biology 7(4): 741-758.

Wagenhoff, A., Shearer, K. & Clapcott, J. 2016. A review of benthic macroinvertebrate metrics for assessing stream ecosystem health. 12 May. Environment Southland. Cawthron Report No. 2852.

Wallace, J.B., Grubaugh, J.W. & Whiles, M.R. 1996. Biotic indices and stream ecosystem processes: Results from an experimental study. Ecological Applications 6(1): 140-151.

Xia, Y.F., Zhang, M., Tsang, D.C.W., Geng, N., Lu, D.B., Zhu, L.F., Igalavithana, A.D., Dissanayake, P.D., Rinklebe, J., Yang, X. & Ok, Y.S. 2020. Recent advances in control technologies for non-point source pollution with nitrogen and phosphorous from agricultural runoff: Current practices and future prospects. Applied Biological Chemistry 63: 8.

Yule, C.M. & Yong, H.S. 2004. Freshwater Invertebrates of the Malaysian Region. Kuala Lumpur: Akademi Sains Malaysia.

Zainudin, E.Z. 2010. Benchmarking river water quality in Malaysia. Jurutera February: 12-15.

Zakaria, M.Z. & Mohamed, M. 2019. Comparative analysis of Biotic Indices in water quality assessment: Case study at Sg. Bantang, Johor. Earth and Environmental Science 269: 012047.

Zamora-Munoz Sainz-Cantero, C.E., Sanchez-Ortega, A. & Alba-Tercedor, J.C. 1995. Are biological indices BMWP and ASTP and their signifance regarding water quality seasonally dependent? Factors explaining their variation. Water Resources 29(1): 285-290.

Zelnik, I. & Muc, T. 2020. Relationship between environmental conditions and structure of macroinvertebrate community in a hydromorphologically altered pre-alpine river. Water 12(11): 2987.

Zhang, M., Wang, B.X., Han, M.H. & Wang, L.H. 2012. Relationships between the seasonal variations of macroinvertebrates, and land uses for biomonitoring in the Xitiaoxi River Watershed, China. International Review of Hydrobiology 97(3): 184-199.

Zolkefli, N., Sharuddin, S.S., Yusoff, M.Z.M., Hassan, M.A., Maeda, T. & Ramli, N. 2020. A review of current and emerging approaches for water pollution monitoring. Water 12: 3417.


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.