Euthanasia and Advanced Medical Directives in the Perspective of Ethical, Moral, Religious and Legal Issues in Malaysia and under Common Law
Abstract
ABSTRACT
Whereas the medical industry has advanced significantly in recent years, there is still much debates around the subject on the legalization of euthanasia and advanced medical directives (‘AMD’). The uncertainty circulates around four different aspects which are ethical, moral, religious and legal. Especially in Malaysia which the nation consists of multicultural and multiracial with diverse beliefs and religions thus, every of those aspects need to be considered thoroughly. This study aims to depict the historical background of euthanasia and AMD which subsequently, in this study will critically analyses the ethical and moral issue arising from euthanasia and AMD based on philosophical thoughts from different school of thoughts. To understand further, this study also aims to study the religious issues based on different religions that arising from euthanasia and AMD. In another aspect, this study will examine the legal issues arising from euthanasia and AMD and suggest the appropriate legal mechanism through critical analysis. This study is conducted by using doctrinal legal research and comparative methods between jurists' opinions, various religions and comparison between Malaysia and Common Law countries. As a result from this study, it is found that euthanasia and AMD are still not widely accepted in the society and still debatable as a whole. Different opinions between various perspectives such as cultures, beliefs, political and society does influence the acceptance of euthanasia and AMD in the society. While in some Common Law countries, euthanasia is legalized as it is needed to end the person’s suffering however in Malaysia, euthanasia is not acceptable as it is related to mercy killing and murder. Therefore, the government need to work alongside with doctors or medical experts by taking account the various aspects in creating a legal framework that is justifiable and fair to the nation in order to legalize euthanasia and AMD in the country.
Keywords: euthanasia, advanced medical directives, AMD, legalization, Malaysia, Common Law.
Full Text:
PDFReferences
REFERENCES
Abakare, C.O. (2021). Legal, Social and Ethical Issues in Euthanasia Jurnal Predestination: Jurnal of Society and Culture, 1(2).
Airedale N.H.S. Trust v Bland [1993] A.C. 789.
Al-Quran.
Andorno, R. et.al. (2007). Advance Health Care Directives: Towards a Coordinated European Policy?, European Journal of Health Law. 16.
Bartels, L. & Otlowski, M. (2010). Right To Die? Euthanasia and the Law in Australia. Journal of Law and Medicine. 17(4): 532-55.
Bradbury, L. W. (2003). Euthanasia in the Netherlands: Recognizing mature minors in euthanasia legislation. New England Journal of International and Comparative Law. 9(1).
Brassington, I. (2020). What Passive Euthanasia Is, BMC Medical Ethics. 21:41 https://doi.org/10.1186/s12910-020-00481-7 [5 May 2021].
Brazier, Y. (2018). Euthanasia And Assisted Suicide: What Are They And What Do They Mean? Medical News Today. https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/182951#euthanasia-and-assisted-suicide-[5 May 2021].
Brody, M. & Cooper, M. W. (2014). Binding and Hoche’s “Life Unworthy of Life”: A Historical and Ethical Analysis. Perspectives in Biology and Medicine. 57(4).
Bulow, H. H. (2008). The World’s Major Religions’ Point of View on End of Life Decision in the Intensive Care Unit. Intensive Care Medicine. Vol. 34, No. 3.
Callahan, D. (1992). When Self-Determination Runs Amok, The Hastings. 22(2), https://doi.org/10.2307/3562566 [2 May 2021].
Costello, M.M. (2018). Natural Law and Its Implication for Medical Assistance-In-Dying. The Journal of International Management Sttudies. 13(1), http://www.jimsjournal.org/3%20Michael%20Costello.pdf [2 May 2021]
Damien Keown and John Keown. (1995). Killing, Karma and Caring: Euthanasia in Buddhism and Christianity. Journal of Medical Ethics. Vol. 21, No. 5. https://www.jstor.org/stable/27717629 [31 May 2021].
Denard Veshi, Gerald Neitzke. (2015). Advance Directives in Some Western European Countries: A Legal and Ethical Comparison between Spain. France, England, and Germany. Eur J Health Law. 22(4). 321-45.
Diaconescu, A.M. (2012). Euthanasia. Contemporary Readings in Law and Social Justice. 4(2).
Dow, L.A. et.al. (2010). Paradoxes in Advance Care Planning: The Complex Relationship of Oncology Patients, Their Physicians, and Advance Medical Directives. Journal of Clinical Oncology. 28(2).
Downie, J. (2016). Permitting voluntary euthanasia and assisted suicide: Law reform pathways for common law jurisdictions. QUT Law Review. 16(1).
Dr Fadhlina Alias & Prof Dr Puteri Nemie Jahn Kassim. (2021). Legal Aspects of End-of-Life’ Care in Malaysia. Malaysian Law Journal, 2(xxxiii): 2. http://irep.iium.edu.my/89416/1/89416_Legal%20Aspects%20of%20End-of-Life%20Care%20in%20Malaysia%20%5B2021%5D%202.pdf [27 February 2022]
Ebrahimi, N. (2012). The Ethics of Euthanasia. Australian Medical Student Journal. https://www.amsj.org/archives/2066 [2 May 2021].
Engelhardt, H.T. & Iltis, A.S. (2005). End of Life: The Traditional Christian View. Lancet. Vol. 366, No. 9490. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(05)67383-7 [31 May 2021].
European Convention of Human Rights Fadhlina Alias, Minkail Muhammas & Puteri Nemie Jahn Kassim. (2015). The legality of euthanasia from the Malaysia and Islamic perspectives: An overview, Medicine and Law. World Association for Medical Law. Vol. 34, ISSN0723-1393.
Federal Constitution.
Ficarra, B. J. (1951). Newer Ethical Problems in Medicine and Surgery, Newman.
Goffin, T. (2012). Advance Directives as an Instrument in an Ageing Europe. European Journal of Health Law. 19.
Grubb. (2001). Euthanasia in England — A Law Lacking Compassion? European Journal of Health Law. 8(2).
Hoffman, S. (2013). Euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide: comparison of E.U. and U.S. law. Syracuse Law Review. 63(3)
Inbadas, H. (2018). Indian Philosophical Foundations of Spirituality at the End of Life. Mortality. Vol. 23, No. 4.
Jamesa. (2016). Utilitarianism View on Euthanasia. Liberrimus. https://sites.dwrl.utexas.edu/liberrimus/2016/10/04/utilitarianism-view-on-euthanasia/ [2 May 2021].
Jehovah’s Witnesses of Moscow and Others V. Russia. [2010] ECHR 135.
Julie A. DiCamillo. (1992). A Comparative Analysis of the Right to Die in the Netherlands and the United States After Cruzan: Reassessing the Right of Self-Determination. 7(4).
Keown, D. (2005). End of Life: The Buddhist View. Lancet. Vol. 366, No. 9849.
Kuhse, H. (1981). Debate: Extraordinary Means and the Sanctity of Life. Journal of Medical Ethics. Vol. 7, No.2.
Lahveenya Panchalingam, Dr Saravanan Mathialagan & Jaganraj Ramachandran. (2019).
Assisted suicide and the right to die: An analysis of the legal position in UK, Canada and Malaysia. Legal Network Series. 1 LNS(A) cxxi.
Leenen, J. (2001). The Development of Euthanasia in the Netherlands. European Journal of Health Law.
Lesco, P. A. (1986). Euthanasia: A Buddhist Perspective. Journal of Religion and Health. Vol. 25, No. 1.
Loewy, E.H. (1998). Ethical Considerations in Executing and Implementing Advance Directives. Archintern Med. 158.
Mahmud Adesina Ayuba. (2016). Euthanasia: A Muslim’s Perspective. Scriptura.https://www.researchgate.net/publication/305310054_Euthanasia_A_Muslim's_perspective. [31 May 2021].
Markwell, H. (2005). End of Life: Jewish Perspective, Lancet, Vol. 366, No. 9491
.
McConnell, P. S. (1990). The Unalienable Right to Life. Journal of Christian Jurisprudence. 8.
Medical Code of Ethics (CME).
MMC Guideline: Consent for Treatment of Patients by Registered Medical Practitioners.
Mohd Zamre Mohd Zahir, et.al. (2019). Patient’s Right to Implement an advance Medical Directive: An Overview. Sains Malaysiana. Vol. 42, (2). http://dx.doi.org/10.17576/jsm-2019-4802-12. [8 June 2021]).
n.a. (2011). Hukum Euthanasia atau mercy killing. E-fatwa JAKIM. http://e smaf.islam.gov.my/e-smaf/index.php/main/mainv1/fatwa/pr/10289. (8 June 2021).
N.a. (2009). Euthanasia, assisted dying, and suicide. BBC News. https://www.bbc.co.uk/religion/religions/hinduism/hinduethics/euthanasia.shtml [3 May 2021].
N.a. (N.d). Ethics - Euthanasia: Forms of euthanasia. BBC. http://www.bbc.co.uk/ethics/euthanasia/overview/forms.shtml [5 May 2021].
N.a. (N.d). Euthanasia. MU School of Medicine. https://medicine.missouri.edu/centersinstitutes-labs/health-ethics/faq/euthanasia [5 May 2021].
Nazeem M. I. Goolam. (1996). Euthanasia: Reconciling culture and human rights. Medicine and Law. Vol. 15, No. 13.
Nelson, G. (2012). Protective Functions of Religious Traditions for Suicide Risk. Suicidology Online. Vol. 3.
Noack, T. & Fangerau, H. (2007). Eugenics, Euthanasia, and Aftermath. International Journal of Mental Health. 36(1).
Noor Akmal Binti Mustafa Kamal & Prof. Madya Dr. Shahrul Mizan Ismail. (2021). Euthanasia: Right To Life as Opposed to Right to Personal Autonomy. Current Law Journal. 1 LNS(A) xl.
Papadimitrou, J.D. et.al. (2007). Euthanasia and suicide in antiquity: viewpoint of the dramatists and philosophers. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine.100, 25-28.
Penal Code (Act 574).
Peters, D. A. (1987). Advance Medical Directives: The case for the durable power for health care. The Journal of Legal Medicine. 8(3).
Porteri, C. (2018). Advance Directives as A Tool To Respect Patients’ Values and Preferences: Discussion on the Case of Alzheimer’s Disease. BMC Medical Ethics. 19(9).
R (on the application of) v Director of Public Prosecutions [2009] UKHL 45.
Rachels, J. (1975). Active and Passive Euthanasia. The New England Journal of Medicine. 292 https://sites.ualberta.ca/~bleier/Rachels_Euthanasia.pdf [2 May 2021].
Re C (Adult: Refusal of Treatment) [1994] 1 All ER 819 (QBD).
Re T (Adult: Refusal of Medical Treatment) [1992] 4 All ER 649 (CA).
Roberto Andorno, Nikola Biller-Andorno and Susanne Brauer (2007), Advance Health Care Directives: Towards a Coordinated European Policy? European Journal of Health Law. 16.
Rohaida Nordin. (2019). Human Right Ideology and Sovereignty-The Malaysian Perspective: Human Right Ideology. Protection of Indigeneous People Rights In Malaysia: State’s Perspective, Obligation and Capacity. Penerbit Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia.
Sahih al-Bukhari, Book 1, Number 159.
Sahih al-Bukhari, Vol. 2, Book 23, Number 445.
Sayed Sikandar Shah Haneef. (1996). Mercy Killing in Islam: Ethical and Legal Issues. Current Law Journal. 3. xcii.
Shaikh Mohd Saifuddeen Shaikh Mohd Salleh. (2015). Persoalan berkaitan Advance Medical Directive (AMD) dalam kerangka bioetika islami. Kertas kerja dibentangkan pada Muzakarah Pakar: Bioetika Islami mengenai Isu Advance Medical Directive (AMD). Kuala Lumpur: Dewan Besar IKIM.
Shao-Yi Cheng, et.al. (2020). Advance care planning in Asian culture. Japanese Journal of Clinical Oncology.
Tan, S. H. (2017). The Case Against Physician-Assisted Suicide and Voluntary Active Euthanasia: A Jurisprudential Consideration. Singapore Academy of Law Journal. 29.
Thomas, C. (2017). The Debate on Euthanasia: Utilitarianism. UKEssays. https://www.ukessays.com/essays/philosophy/debate-euthanasia-utilitarianism-3628.php [2 May 2021].
Tom Goffin. (2012). Advance Directives as an Instrument in an Ageing Europe. European Journal of Health Law. 19.
Toner, M. S. (2003). How Buddhism Influences Pain Control Choices. Nursing. Firth, S. 2005.
End of Life: A Hindu view. Lancet. Vol. 366, No. 9486.
Washington v Glucksberg US 702 (1997) USSC
Williams, G. (1965). Euthanasia and abortion. University of Colorado Law Review. 38(2).
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.
e-ISSN : 2550-1704